Marc Maron

Character: Mel

Jon Bass

Character: Nathaniel

Michaela Watkins

Character: Mary

Jillian Bell

Character: Cynthia

Toby Huss

Character: Hog Jaws

Dan Bakkedahl

Character: Kingpin

Lynn Shelton

Character: Deirdre

Timothy Paul

Character: Zeke

Whitmer Thomas

Character: Jake

Al Elliott

Character: Jimmy

Tilcia Furman

Character: Gabby

Benjamin Keepers

Character: Ben

Robert Longstreet

Character: Truther

Elise Mayfield

Character: Phyllis

T'Darius Murphy

Character: Mechanic

Michael Patrick O'Brien

Character: Yach

Chris Steele

Character: Boyfriend (uncredited)

Elisha Williams

Character: Girlfriend (uncredited)

John Winscher

Character: Civil War Conspirator (uncredited)