Jessica Chastain

Character: Tammy Faye Bakker

Andrew Garfield

Character: Jim Bakker

Cherry Jones

Character: Rachel Grover

Vincent D'Onofrio

Character: Jerry Falwell

Mark Wystrach

Character: Gary Paxton

Sam Jaeger

Character: Roe Messner

Louis Cancelmi

Character: Richard Fletcher

Gabriel Olds

Character: Pat Robertson

Fredric Lehne

Character: Fred Grover

Chandler Head

Character: Little Tammy Faye

Jay Huguley

Character: Jimmy Swaggart

Dan Johnson

Character: Preacher

Michael MacCauley

Character: Big Man

Grant Owens

Character: Colonel Sanders

Coley Campany

Character: DeDe Robertson

Craig Newkirk

Character: Doctor

Wes Jetton

Character: Male Nurse

Jess Weixler

Character: Makeup Artist (voice)

Maurie Speed

Character: Nurse

Lindsay Ayliffe

Character: Old Teacher (Bible College)

Julie P. Tuggle

Character: Pledge Lady

Kimberly Ann Parker

Character: Reporter

Dana Marks

Character: True Believer

Alan Boell

Character: Stephen Chow

Randy Havens

Character: Steve Pieters

Lila Jane Meadows

Character: Tammy Sue

Carolyn Mints

Character: Wanda

Kelly Borgnis

Character: PTL Patron

Kelsi Chandler

Character: PTL Patron

Joe Ando-Hirsh

Character: Teenage Punk #1

John Johnson

Character: Teenage Punk #2

Grayson Carter

Character: Teenage Punk #3

Callie Lipian

Character: Jamie Charles Bakker (Baby)

Caroline Lipian

Character: Tammy Sue Bakker (Baby)

Robert Bailey

Character: Nashville Singer

Deb Thomas Cox

Character: Nashville Singer

Ellen Dockery

Character: Nashville Singer

Jana King Evans

Character: Nashville Singer

Lee Hilliard

Character: Nashville Singer

Mark Ivey

Character: Nashville Singer

Michael B. Lusk

Character: Nashville Singer

Craig Morris

Character: Nashville Singer

Savannah Morris

Character: Nashville Singer

Donna Rhodes

Character: Nashville Singer

Kira Small

Character: Nashville Singer

Allen Andrews

Character: PTL Sax Player (uncredited)

Chris TC Edge

Character: PTL Crew Member (uncredited)

Kyle Riggs

Character: Jamie Charles Bakker (uncredited)

Alan Dale

Character: Self (archive Footage)

Hugh Downs

Character: Self (archive Footage)

Jay Leno

Character: Self (archive Footage)

Ronald Reagan

Character: Self (archive Footage)

Christian Goins

Character: Little Danny