Greg Kinnear

Character: Phil

Emily Mortimer

Character: Alicia

Taylor Schilling

Character: Sam

Kurt Fuller

Character: Jerome

Bradley Whitford

Character: Michael Fisk

Luke Wilson

Character: Detective Welling

April Cameron

Character: Rahel

Megan Charpentier

Character: Molly McGuire

Sarah Dugdale

Character: Kara Fisk

Jay Duplass

Character: Malcolm

Robert Forster

Character: Bing Fisk

Christina Jastrzembska

Character: Mrs. Konwiser

Jagen Johnson

Character: Booze Clerk

Angela Moore

Character: Nurse

Nicole Oliver

Character: Rosemary

William B. Davis

Character: Father Grant

Rukiya Bernard

Character: Nora

Peter Bryant

Character: Cop

Kirby Morrow

Character: Childhood Friend

Brittany Mitchell

Character: Nurse 2 / Pizza Server

Alex Trebek

Character: Alex Trebek

Doug Abrahams

Character: Maître D'