Robert Wagner

Character: Gilbert Barrows

Dolores Hart

Character: Elinor Harrison

Ernie Kovacs

Character: Bugsy G. Foglemeyer aka The Captain

Frankie Avalon

Character: Ens. Rodney J. Foglemeyer

Frank Gorshin

Character: George M. Wilson

Harvey Lembeck

Character: Nickels

Sid Tomack

Character: Sammy

Guy Raymond

Character: Helmut

Buck Kartalian

Character: Finster

Wilton Graff

Character: Simon J. Harrison

Marjorie Bennett

Character: Mrs. Chowder

Carolyn Jones

Character: Virginia

Jesse White

Character: McDonald

Hal Taggart

Character: Pilgrim at Turkey Giveaway

Hope Sansberry

Character: Biddy

Howard Wendell

Character: Mr. Caldingham (uncredited)

Hal Taggart

Character: Pilgrim at Turkey Giveaway (uncredited)

Tom Symonds

Character: Second Man (uncredited)

Robert Stevenson

Character: Coast Guard Officer (uncredited)

Cosmo Sardo

Character: Man in Bank (uncredited)

Hope Sansberry

Character: Biddy (uncredited)

Bru Mysak

Character: Newsboy (uncredited)

Terry Huntingdon

Character: Young Lady Pilgrim (uncredited)

Graeme Ferguson

Character: First Man (uncredited)