Ema Horvath

Character: Alex

Yeardley Smith

Character: Sarah

John Ales

Character: Carey

Alyssa Milano

Character: Judith

Siddharth Dhananjay

Character: Rohan

Reid Miller

Character: Arthur

Peter Parros

Character: Reggie

Devon Sawa

Character: Karl

Kiah Butts

Character: Nancy

Keziah Wall

Character: Eliza

Delyn Wall

Character: Rose

Jenna Louie Lohouse

Character: Gayle

Duffy Epstein

Character: Beau

Jeanine Jackson

Character: Substitute Teacher

Lauren Wafer

Character: Mean Girl

Elizabeth Huffman

Character: Headmistress

Rob Nelson

Character: Lyft Driver

Laura Duyn

Character: Minister

Wolfie Beacham

Character: Delivery Guy

Suzanne Owens-Duval

Character: Grandmother

Ayanna Berkshire

Character: Therapist

A. Brian Daniels

Character: Party Guest

A. Brian Daniels

Character: Party Guest

Xzavier Beacham

Character: Pizza Guy

Carlo Hernandez

Character: Church Couple (Man)

Naomi Klockars

Character: Student

Debbie Marr

Character: Church Member

Elizabeth O'Brien

Character: Student