Ikechukwu Ufomadu

Character: Inspector Ike

Matt Barats

Character: Harry Newcombe

Ana Fabrega

Character: Deputy Hawthorne

Grace Rex

Character: Jan

John Early

Character: Chip Conrad

Aparna Nancherla

Character: Fran

Anthony Oberbeck

Character: Deputy Dinardo

Jessica Damouni

Character: Rita Conrad

Dorothi Fox

Character: Esther

Alex Goldberg

Character: Al

River L. Ramirez

Character: Loretta

Stavros Halkias

Character: Confused Waiter for 'Al's Pizza'

Colin Burgess

Character: Actor

Eudora Peterson

Character: Actor

Caroline Yost

Character: Actor

Dan Arnes

Character: Wealthy Criminal

Rhys Grady

Character: Christmas Criminal

Amy Zimmer

Character: Stage Magician

Tynan DeLong

Character: Phantom

Carly Lovejoy

Character: Rockette

Leah Motzkin

Character: Rockette

Sarah Madden

Character: Rockette

Alex Tatarsky

Character: Mime

Ryan McGlade

Character: Kabuki Guy

Jen Goma

Character: Actor

Mike McKay

Character: TV Announcer