Justin Hartley

Character: Jacob Turner

Barrett Doss

Character: Rachel Campbell

Bonnie Bedelia

Character: Ellie Foster

Essence Atkins

Character: Noel Hayden

James Remar

Character: Scott Turner

Aaron Costa Ganis

Character: Matt Segreto

Jeff Corbett

Character: Ian Page

Andrea Sooch

Character: Svetlana

Lucia Spina

Character: Book Store Owner

Shelby Reitman Renee

Character: Young Noel

Vivian Full

Character: Shari

Mike Donovan

Character: Alan

Whitney Kimball Long

Character: Attractive Fan

Monica McCarthy

Character: Lois Turner

Samantha Smart

Character: Vamp Fan

Baylen D. Bielitz

Character: Benjamin Turner

Gina D'Acciaro

Character: Waitress

Lauren Yaffe

Character: Fan

Alexander Blaise

Character: Vittorio

Hollis Kempain Abram

Character: Townsfolk

Blaine Morris

Character: Nurse Cindy

Patrick K. Dooley

Character: Todd

Marilyn Busch

Character: Fifty-Something Fan

Kathleen Mary Carthy

Character: Candlelight Inn Receptionist

William DeMeritt

Character: Dion