Brooke Bradshaw

Character: Veronica (New Years)

Wesley Alley

Character: Uncle Bob (Christmas)

Whitney Alley

Character: Party Guest (Christmas)

Michael Antosy

Character: Eran Lawrence (Easter)

Amy Baklini

Character: Doctor's Voicemail (voice)

Ronan Barbour

Character: Doyle (St. Patrick's Day)

Adam Beigel

Character: Kris Anderson (Christmas)

Michelle Bernard

Character: Judy (Chanukah)

Darren Lynn Bousman

Character: Orignial Killer Santa (Christmas)

Alexandra Boylan

Character: Josi (Thanksgiving)

Arielle Brachfeld

Character: Girl in Woods (Halloween)

Hannah Carleton

Character: Home Buyer (Halloween)

Brian C. Chenworth

Character: New Killer Santa Clause (Christmas)

Micah Cohen

Character: Party Goer (New Years)

Brandon Conner

Character: Jeffery (Halloween)

Ivet Corvea

Character: Gloria (4th of July)

Francis Cronin

Character: Sheamus G (St. Patrick's Day)

Taylor Cross

Character: Dan (New Years)

Lenora Elisabeth

Character: Ciara (St. Patrick's Day)

Michael J. Epstein

Character: Mr. Keane (St. Patrick's Day)

Bradley Fowler

Character: Party Guest (Christmas)

Charlie Frohne

Character: Radio News Reporter (Easter) (voice)

John K.D. Graham

Character: Monster (Thanksgiving)

Josh Hammond

Character: Jesse (4th of July)

Alethea Hnatko-Cho

Character: Clara (St. Patrick's Day)

Christopher M. Jimenez

Character: Party Guest (Christmas)

Breeanna Judy

Character: Party Guest (Christmas)

Darius Karsas

Character: Father Time (New Years)

Neil King

Character: Party Guest (Christmas)

Erica Lamkin

Character: Laura (Labor Day)

Matt Larson

Character: Allen (New Years)

Lisa Mason Lee

Character: Diane (New Years)

Bobbi Sue Luther

Character: Party Guest (Christmas)

Rene Michelle Aranda

Character: Party Goer (New Years)

Micah Cohler

Character: Party Guest (New Years / Father Time)

Raiven Lynn

Character: Shawna (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Andrew Maiorano

Character: Raven Entity (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)

Hercules Magnus

Character: Hercules (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)

Amanda Markowitz

Character: Tara / Party Game Player 2 (New Years / Father Time)

Kevin Marron

Character: Mr. G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)

Victoria Matlock

Character: Jessica / Party Game Player 1 (New Years / Father Time)

Marty McFly

Character: Marty (Easter / Forty Winks)

Brian McGrath

Character: Strange Walker (Easter / Forty Winks)

Matt McWilliams

Character: Home Buyer (Halloween / Candy)

Nell Nakkan

Character: Mrs. Keane (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)

Maitlyn Pezzo

Character: Holly (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Jodie Panek

Character: Mom (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)

Demetrius Phillips

Character: Kevin (4th of July / 4th of July)

Nicolas Quijano

Character: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Rachel Rath

Character: Mrs. G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)

Patrick Joseph Rieger

Character: Mike (Halloween / Candy)

Benton Robertson

Character: Patrick G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)

Charlotte Rothwell

Character: TV News Reporter (Easter / Forty Winks) (voice)

Angelica Salek

Character: Beth Anderson (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Brian Sapir

Character: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Curtis Schultz

Character: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Daniel Schweiger

Character: Soloman (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)

Steven Shea

Character: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Bright)

Catherine Siggins

Character: Aunty Lorna McGlory (St. Patrick's / Becoming Patrick)

Dan Snowden

Character: Real Estate Man (Halloween / Candy)

Jessica Sonneborn

Character: Jane / Betty (4th of July / 4th of July, Labor Day / Labor Day)

Michael Varrati

Character: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Jennifer Vincent

Character: Crystal (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)

Jeff Wiesen

Character: Cop / James (4th of July / 4th of July, Labor Day / Labor Day)

Wes Sneeringer

Character: 911 Operator (uncredited)

Khaled Zakher

Character: Store Clerk (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)

Lauren Chavez-Myers

Character: Lilith Hicks (Easter)

DaNae Martinez

Character: Charlotte Anderson (Christmas / Merry and Fright)