Justin McElroy

Character: Self / Chris Evergreen

Travis McElroy

Character: Self

Griffin McElroy

Character: Self

Sydnee McElroy

Character: Self / Tabitha Bigcity

Teylor Smirl

Character: Self / Tabitha's Friend

Rachel McElroy

Character: Self

Tommy Smirl

Character: Self / Tabitha's Dad

Teresa McElroy

Character: Self

Barbara Dunkelman

Character: Self

Clint McElroy

Character: Santa Clause

Carol McElroy

Character: Professor Clause

Matt Chapman

Character: Strong Bad (Voice) / Homestar Runner (Voice)

Rob Corddry

Character: Self

Lin-Manuel Miranda

Character: Self

Laser Malena-Webber

Character: Self

Aubrey Turner

Character: Self

Erika Ishii

Character: Self

Amanda Coleman

Character: Self

Mara Wilson

Character: Self

Felicia Day

Character: Self

Charlie McElroy

Character: Self

Bebe McElroy

Character: Self

Henry McElroy

Character: Self

Ron Funches

Character: Self

Jeremiah Watkins

Character: Self

Ben Schwartz

Character: Self

Mary Smirl

Character: Chris' Mom

Melissa Fumero

Character: Self

Krystina Arielle

Character: Self

Dwight Slappe

Character: Jesus Impersonator