Cara Buono

Character: Heather McCalister

Clare Foley

Character: Lauren Davis

Spencer List

Character: Peter McCalister

William Sadler

Character: Gilbert McCalister

Michael Park

Character: Officer Matthews

Tyler Elliot Burke

Character: Shawn McCalister

Adam Weppler

Character: Dylan

Ehad Berisha

Character: Mike

Giselle Torres

Character: Veronica

Dan Leahy

Character: Ben

Sienna Hubert-Ross

Character: Ashley

Erik Bloomquist

Character: Danny

Emily McMurtry

Character: Kellie

Tess Santarsiero

Character: Martha

Declan Foley

Character: Tommy

Coulter Ibanez

Character: Dennis

Cory Asinofsky

Character: Pizza Guy

Cody Boccia

Character: Deputy Barnett

Madeleine Dauer

Character: Agatha

Juliana Davies

Character: Young Heather

Emily Rafala

Character: Evelyn