Mira Sorvino

Character: Elaine

Joe Pantoliano

Character: Oswald

Ryan Simpkins

Character: Lizzy Muldoun

Michael Urie

Character: James

Maxwell Beer

Character: Jeremy Fink

Steve Grodewald

Character: Tattooed guy

Ryan Glassman

Character: Rick

Christopher King

Character: Garlic Man

Amelia Bullock

Character: Girl Scout

Evan Trevor Thompson

Character: Clay

Marian Seldes

Character: Mabel Billingsly

Heather Braverman

Character: Samantha

Roscoe Orman

Character: Dr. Grady

Betsy Brandt

Character: Madame Zaleski

Seth Kanor

Character: Jeremy's Dad (voice)

Daniel Cosgrove

Character: Herb Muldoun

Mike Starr

Character: Officer Polansky

Gavin Furbert

Character: Security Guard

Markley Rizzi

Character: Mary

Nimo Gandhi

Character: Fred

Michael Pemberton

Character: Doorman

Joe Huu

Character: Shady Character #1

Eddie Perry

Character: Shady Character #2

David Thornton

Character: Simon Rudolph

Jacob Michel

Character: Cassius

Wendy Mass

Character: Wendy

Gary Allen

Character: Larry

Ngo Okafor

Character: Sebastian

Bill Walters

Character: Homeless Dude