Paul Newman

Character: Henry Gondorff

Robert Redford

Character: Johnny Hooker

Robert Shaw

Character: Doyle Lonnegan

Charles Durning

Character: Lt. Wm. Snyder

Ray Walston

Character: J.J. Singleton

Eileen Brennan

Character: Billie

Harold Gould

Character: Kid Twist

John Heffernan

Character: Eddie Niles

Dana Elcar

Character: F.B.I. Agent Polk

Jack Kehoe

Character: Erie Kid

Dimitra Arliss

Character: Loretta

Robert Earl Jones

Character: Luther Coleman

James Sloyan

Character: Mottola

Charles Dierkop

Character: Floyd (Bodyguard)

Lee Paul

Character: Bodyguard

Sally Kirkland

Character: Crystal

Avon Long

Character: Benny Garfield

Arch Johnson

Character: Combs

Ed Bakey

Character: Granger

Brad Sullivan

Character: Cole

John Quade

Character: Riley

Larry D. Mann

Character: Train Conductor

Leonard Barr

Character: Burlesque House Comedian

Paulene Myers

Character: Alva Coleman

Joe Tornatore

Character: Black Gloved Gunman

Jack Collins

Character: Duke Boudreau

Tom Spratley

Character: Curly Jackson

Kenneth O'Brien

Character: Greer

Ken Sansom

Character: Western Union Executive

Ta-Tanisha

Character: Louise Coleman

William Benedict

Character: Roulette Dealer

Robert Brubaker

Character: Bill Clayton from Pittsburgh (uncredited)

Kathleen Freeman

Character: Kid Twist's Wife (uncredited)

Susan French

Character: Landlady (uncredited)

Bruce Kimball

Character: Lacey the Bouncer (uncredited)

Alexander Lockwood

Character: Landlord (uncredited)

Chuck Morrell

Character: FBI Agent Chuck (uncredited)

Byron Morrow

Character: Mr. Jameson from Chicago (uncredited)

Pearl Shear

Character: Lady in Phone Booth (uncredited)

Arthur Tovey

Character: Bank Officer (uncredited)

Guy Way

Character: Gambling Den Boss (uncredited)

Jim Michael

Character: Bartender (uncredited)

Jack Berle

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Nick Borgani

Character: Tailor (uncredited)

Robert Buckingham

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Peter Eastman

Character: Poker Player (uncredited)

Richard Elmore

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Bob Folkerson

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Sig Frohlich

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Ralph Gambina

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Clarke Gordon

Character: Mr. Lombard (uncredited)

Jack Griffin

Character: Cabbie (uncredited)

Bob Harks

Character: Pedestrian (uncredited)

George Holmes

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Sid Kane

Character: Cashier #2 (uncredited)

Mike Lally

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Tom McDonough

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Richard Niehaus

Character: Train Passenger (uncredited)

Jessica Rains

Character: Secretary (uncredited)

Al Roberts

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Edwin Rochelle

Character: Gambler (uncredited)

Clark Ross

Character: Man at Bar (uncredited)