Stewart Granger

Character: Old Surehand

Pierre Brice

Character: Winnetou

Elke Sommer

Character: Annie Dillman

Götz George

Character: Martin Baumann Jr.

Walter Barnes

Character: Martin Baumann Sr.

Renato Baldini

Character: Judge Leader

Terence Hill

Character: Baker Jr.

Sieghardt Rupp

Character: Preston

Milan Srdoč

Character: Old Wabble

Miha Baloh

Character: 'Reverend' Weller

Louis Velle

Character: Gordon

Gojko Mitić

Character: Wokadeh

Dunja Rajter

Character: Betsy (uncredited)

Voja Mirić

Character: Stewart

Ilija Ivezić

Character: Jackie

Đorđe Nenadović

Character: Miller

Nevenka Benković

Character: Settler woman (uncredited)

Šime Jagarinac

Character: Schoschone (uncredited)