Misha Collins

Character: Paul Bernardo

Laura Prepon

Character: Karla Homolka

Brandon Routh

Character: Tim

Patrick Bauchau

Character: Dr. Arnold

Emilie Jacobs

Character: Debbie

Adam Lieberman

Character: Detective Morgan

Shawn Hoffman

Character: Detective Steve Kirby

William Duffy

Character: Detective Porter

Alex Boyd

Character: Nick

Cherilyn Hayres

Character: Tammy Homolka

Kristen Honey

Character: Tina McCarthy (as Kristen Swieconek)

Cole James

Character: Tina's Friend

Carole Ita White

Character: Waitress

Fiona Manners

Character: Rape Victim #1

Tanya Lemelle

Character: Rape Victim #2

Tony Shawkat

Character: Border Guard #1

Tess Harper

Character: Molly

Leonard Kelly-Young

Character: Dan

Anna Pheil

Character: Patricia

Zach DiLiberto

Character: Doug

Nikki McCauley

Character: Jessie

Sarah Foret

Character: Kaitlyn Ross

Tony Denison

Character: Detective Burroughs

Jeff Doucette

Character: Burroughs's Partner

Bunny Gibson

Character: Mrs. Ross

Bradford English

Character: Mr. Ross

John Ross Clark

Character: Attorney Warner

Philippe Bergeron

Character: Attorney Siegel

Eileen Dietz

Character: Helen

Ross Patterson

Character: Steve