Dean Cain

Character: Pastor Keith Atkins

James Dickey

Character: Eugene

Sarah Turner Holland

Character: Anita Atkins

Eileen Lacer

Character: Charlotte Drake (adult)

Bobby Lacer

Character: Dexter Drake (John Doe)

Sandra Gabhart

Character: Gigi

Michael Bucci

Character: Frank Masseria

Shane Yuhas

Character: Angelo

Rae Hunt

Character: Principal Wallace