Candace Cameron Bure

Character: Aurora Teagarden

Niall Matter

Character: Nick Miller

Marilu Henner

Character: Aida Teagarden

Miranda Frigon

Character: Lynn Smith

Dylan Sloane

Character: Phillip Pifer

Brad Harder

Character: Sergeant Charlie Heard

Ellie Harvie

Character: Lillian Tibbett

Julia Benson

Character: Lizzie

Cole Vigue

Character: Davis Mettle

Kendall Cross

Character: Terry Hall

Ben Cockell

Character: Jacob Hall

Jaycie Dotin

Character: Sharon Patterson

Tyler McClendon

Character: Russ Slocum

Mike Carpenter

Character: Cliff Minton

Mark Gibbon

Character: Donald Heller

Ronald Patrick Thompson

Character: Tom

Lydia Campbell

Character: Holly

Dhirendra

Character: Motel Manager

Nhi Do

Character: Jenna

Brian Cyburt

Character: Brandon